Feuds are pointless tragedies carried out for political, religious or personal honor, thrust upon generation after generation, father to son.
– Jayne Ann Phillips

During visits to the castles of Aberdeenshire in Scotland, we learned about a centuries-old feud between the Irvines at Castle Drum and Clan Keith whose family seat was in Dunnottar Castle. Fueled by a vicious cycle of revenge killings, the quarrel lingered for more than thirty generations.
In the beginning
Tensions began under King Robert the Bruce. When Bruce’s Scots defeated the English in the Battle of Bannockburn, the king granted his loyal armor bearer William de Irwyne (later Irvine) the Barony of Drum. The land was north of the River Dee and adjacent to the powerful Keith clan where their massive estates dominated the region including Hallforest Castle and Dunnottar, the imposing seaside fortress outside Stonehaven.





As the two clans squabbled over timber resources, hunting rights and territorial disputes, the clash turned deadly. When Keith clansmen captured one of the Irvine children and burned the boy alive, the Irvines raided Keith territory northwest of Aberdeen and burned the strategic Hallford Castle to the ground.
The escalation of war
Violence between the clans culminated in 1402. After a Keith raiding party crossed the River Dee to plunder Irvine lands, they were intercepted as they attempted to flee back across the river with their booty. In what would be known as the Battle of Drumoak, the clash quickly turned into a slaughter.
As the Irvines drove the Keiths into a deep, rocky stretch of water, the Keith men drowned in the swift, swirling river, a place that would forever bear the name Keith’s Pot. As his men vanished beneath the waters, the leading Keith clansman clawed his way to safety, scrambling up an isolated rock in the middle of the river. Though sheltered from drowning, he was still within range of Irvine’s deadly archers. With no means of escape, Keith was quickly shot and killed. The rock on which he died was renamed The Keith Stone.


Royal interference
To stop the bloodshed, King Robert III stepped in and formed a political alliance between the families. By forcing marriage between the Laird of Drum’s eldest son, Alexander Irvine to the daughter of the Keith chief, Elizabeth Keith, the king ended open warfare between the clans. But he couldn’t build instant family bonds, and when Alexander refused to consummate the marriage, the union failed to produce an heir.

Unfinished business
Though active hostilities ceased, the clan dispute was never formally settled. It remained open on feudal registries until early this century.
On August 4, 2002, David Irvine, the 26th Baron of Drum and Michael Keith, the 13th Earl of Kintore and Chief of Clan Keith met midway across Park Bridge on the River Dee at the historical boundary between their two ancestral holdings. There, the men shook hands and signed a treaty. It was notarized by the Marquess of Huntly.
Following the armistice, a 600-year-old Scottish family feud finally ended.

Wow! Talk about holding a grudge! Great history story!